Rene Ritchie, the official YouTube Creator Liaison and a veteran tech analyst, recently addressed the growing anxiety among digital creators regarding shadowbanning, AI-generated content, and fluctuating view counts.
Speaking on a recent podcast hosted by Travis McPherson of vidIQ, a leading YouTube growth and analytics platform, Ritchie provided an inside look at the platform’s internal logic.
He emphasized that the discovery system is designed to pull videos for viewers based on their interests rather than pushing content for creators, a distinction that clarifies many common misconceptions about the algorithm.
Addressing the controversial topic of shadowbanning (the practice of a platform limiting a video’s reach without notifying the creator), Ritchie stated that most performance drops are tied to audience shifts rather than hidden penalties.
He explained that many creators conflate correlation with causation, especially regarding monetization status. While a video might be demonetized for mature themes, a simultaneous drop in reach is often the result of the discovery system independently deciding the content is not appropriate for a general audience, rather than a direct punishment for the lack of ads.
Regarding the rise of Artificial Intelligence, Ritchie clarified that YouTube does not have a specific policy against AI-generated videos, provided they meet quality standards. He noted that the platform’s focus is on authenticity and original value rather than the specific tools used.
Creators using AI are required to check a disclosure box if the content is synthetic or significantly altered to prevent viewer confusion, but Ritchie confirmed that this label does not artificially limit a video’s reach in the discovery system.
For creators experiencing a plateau after changing their content niche, Ritchie warned that “pivoting is hard” because the audience often follows a topic rather than an individual.
He compared a channel pivot to a favourite Italian restaurant suddenly serving Cantonese food; while a few loyal fans might stay, the restaurant loses its core customer base.
He suggested that creators should treat a major shift in topic as starting a new channel, requiring fresh investment to build a relevant audience from scratch.
Ritchie also solved a recent mystery involving major channels like Linus Tech Tips, which reported a sudden drop in desktop views despite steady engagement.
He revealed the cause was an update in third-party ad-blocking software that inadvertently blocked the telemetry (data signals used to track activity) that YouTube uses to register a view.
This meant that while people were watching and liking the videos, the data signal never reached YouTube’s servers, though he noted this issue has since been largely resolved.
A former independent creator with over 300,000 subscribers on his own technology channel, Ritchie was appointed as the Creator Liaison in 2022. His role serves as a bridge between the company’s product teams and the millions of individuals who make a living on the platform.
He encourages creators to focus on their “unique voice,” noting that the most successful faceless channels thrive because they offer a distinct perspective that cannot be easily replicated by machines.
